Rating: Negative Comment: A trade back in late '08. Trader lied that they had their trade after I sent my trade off. I feel very ripped off. I still have your address, if you want me to take this negative off, inquire with me first. Rated by: Mikilane Date: 2011-08-19 22:30:00
Rating: Neutral Comment: Trader returned half of my items along with other items as replacement. Rated by: shiichi Date: 2009-08-18 11:12:01
Rating: Negative Comment: I bought a Naraku figure from this trader, and they never sent it. So my friend never got her Christmas gift. Rated by: wolfy2491 Date: 2009-06-09 22:25:34
Rating: Neutral Comment: She told me she would send me $45 and she did, I'm glad she is trying to make up for her mistakes Rated by: Stormer Date: 2009-04-13 16:51:36
Rating: Neutral Comment: She told me she would send me $45 and she did, I'm glad she is trying to make up for her mistakes Rated by: Stormer Date: 2009-04-13 16:51:29
Rating: Negative Comment: Never recieved my trade items. Promised to send back my items but two months after my items were sent I have yet to recieve anything Rated by: Black_Kite Date: 2009-02-28 20:01:54
Rating: Negative Comment: DO NOT TRADE WITH THIS PERSON!!! Agreed to trade on Dec. 11, 2008. Traded: Suppli Vol 1 2 3 manga, Solty Rei Vol. 1 dvd BRAND NEW, Strait Jacket dvd, Red River Vol 1 2 3 manga. For: Ouran High School 1-10. Its almost Feb now and still haven't received anything. Also Shiori has quit replying to her email/messages on mangatude. Last I heard was from quote 2 from below. I wasnt planning on giving negative feedback but from what I see now i'm not the only one and its not a shipping problem. I also had an uneasy feeling when with this trade right after the quote 1 from below. Her feedback was clean and all positives when I 1st did this trade. I'm still hoping to get my items in and I will think about reconsider changing the feedback.
These are some quotes from Shiori Q1:"2008-12-16 11:12:47 ... I do have the items. I'm saying when I get the promised package. It says right on my page that because people haven't been sending their packages, I won't send mine until I get my end of the deal." Q2:"2009-01-10 11:01:26 ... it'll get there. Apparently, the government is going through all my packaging, so it takes longer for my stuff to get there."
Rated by: kookie Date: 2009-01-27 11:13:22
Rating: Neutral Comment: Agreed on a trade they offered, but after a couple months I just got the book I sent her back. Her message on the main page doesn't give any explanation for what happened and why so many trades got botched up. I wouldn't mind if there was just more communication over what happened. Doesn't seem to matter much now since she's basically deleted her account but just in case she reads this, I'm not really angry since I got it back but I wish you'd have talked to us about this. Rated by: eecomics Date: 2009-01-24 15:44:48
Rating: Neutral Comment: I have changed my rating to reflect the fact that I did indeed receive the two games I had traded for. Looking over the feedback, I realize that I was almost the victim of a scam. She offered me some books that were on my wishlist, but I instead asked for some games that were on her tradelist. Luckily, she actually had those items and so I was able to receive them (eventually). I'm very happy because they are Christmas presents for my kids. Thank you, Shiori, for making right with me, I hope you do the same for the other members on Mangatude. Rated by: AsimovGirl Date: 2009-01-23 16:05:17
Rating: Negative Comment: Agreed on November 23 to send out books.
Sent mine, but I never got her's. Rated by: Toxicbullets Date: 2009-01-21 14:22:06
Rating: Negative Comment: Autumn French has also fucked me over, big time. I'm out six books or so. Only now is she apologizing. If she makes reparations, I will change my feedback. But it looks like she's got sixteen other angry people to deal with, so I'm not holding my breath. Rated by: usagi Date: 2009-01-21 00:00:52
Rating: Negative Comment: I'm yet another person who never received my books. On November 25th we agreed to trade my Le Chevalier D'Eon vol. 1-3 and Complete Japanese audio set for her Tsubasa 6-10. I mailed on November 26th and was told on December 11th that they had been received. I was also told that the Tsubasa books would be mailed to me on December 12. That is the last contact I have had, other than the automated message on December 27th. It's too bad that Shiori isn't able to be mature and handle the trades when so many others on here are so nice. Disappointing. Rated by: snow Date: 2009-01-20 19:48:44
Rating: Negative Comment: Guess I'll add my experience. I got hit at the beginning of December. I got that "back in January" message after I sent mine, and nothing since. Since Autumn seems to have decided to cut and bale, I'm leaving this negative rating, but I'm not holding my breath that I'll get my book. At least it was only one book and not one I really cared about. It was the one I was trading for that I wanted. Don't let this sour you to trading. I still think it's a great way to get books. But, there's always a bad apple in the cart. Rated by: mangaxanadu Date: 2009-01-19 23:34:43
Rating: Negative Comment: Yeah, Autumn French has cheated me as well. I'm down three manga books and two bootleg dvd sets... Heh. Yeah she got me good. I already tried twice to sell those sets on ebay though and no one wanted them so.. Good luck trying to get rid of those! At least the dvd sets were bootlegs Defintily a cheat and a liar. She used to be a decent trader but then decided to start cheating everyone for some reason. I guess it was inevitable that we'd eventually get a big crook on this site, but it's still sad. Rated by: ashez2ashes Date: 2009-01-19 12:15:19
Rating: Negative Comment: Only after I accepted a trade from Shiori did this negative feedback start flooding in. And I see why. In the trade, I had sent out the DVD a few days before December 25, and afterwards she posted saying that she would be coming back from vacation on January 6th. She hasn't said anything else since that post. I will change this review if I ever get what I was promised, but it is doubted seeing as she has deleted all of her items and friends and the like. Rated by: the_shouted Date: 2009-01-19 09:46:13
Rating: Negative Comment: Agreed to trade on Dec. 16, 2008. I sent mine on Dec. 29. Shiori replied back on Jan 6, saying, "Received and sent." I know it hasn't been too long since she claimed to have sent the manga but after seeing all the negative feedback she has gotten so far, I have to believe she lied. I thought this member could be trusted since she received 36 postive feedbacks. I was surprised to find out that she lied and stole from other members. To have paid shipping and not get anything in return is upsetting. She has logged on today but has not return any of my messages. Instead, she cleared out her wishlist and trade list and changed her location to "jg, nmb." I'm hoping she will do the honest thing and send all books to everybody she has promised but I doubt it. Rated by: Daisy Date: 2009-01-18 18:50:32
Rating: Negative Comment: I shipped out my item on 12/01/08 and shiori claims to have not recieved it. At first i thought maybe my package got lost in the mail but after seeing the comments other people have left Shiori I believe that the book was recieved. Rated by: mangaramen Date: 2009-01-18 02:10:48
Rating: Negative Comment: DO NOT TRADE WITH THIS PERSON!!! they don't send out what they are offering and i have contacted kristen about it so hopefully it will be resolved. Rated by: hil34 Date: 2009-01-17 19:46:20
Rating: Negative Comment: agreed to a trade in late november, shipped my items on 12/10
has obviously received them by now, won't send me my items and claims the government and her don't get along as to a reasoning why I haven't received my package.
HUGE SCAMMER, AND LIAR!
STAY AWAY FROM!!!!
This feedback will be changed should I ever receive my books.
Rated by: Leannarchy Date: 2009-01-17 13:46:18
Rating: Negative Comment: I agreed to trade in early Dec. I traded two more books away. Now, I feel extremely STUPID..and very upset now due to getting nothing in return. I will change my feedback once I get whatever was promised! Rated by: CC Date: 2009-01-16 18:40:06
Rating: Negative Comment: We agreed to trade in Nov 20. It is now Jan 16th! I traded away Dazzle 8 and I got ABSOLUTELY NOTHING. There seems to be several people not receiving their books. At first, I give the benefit of my doubt due to packages that might be lost to mail. But, now, after so long and not a even good response to my concern. I feel that person is EXTREMELY suspicious. Shiori first approached me with the offer and then I agreed because it was a book of my interest. I am VERY upset about this. Rated by: CC Date: 2009-01-16 18:34:52
Rating: Negative Comment: Two months, and three or four lies later, I still don't have my book and this trader has become unresponsive. Anyone still trading with her better think twice before agreeing to her profile demands. Rated by: JoBean Date: 2009-01-16 14:27:15
Rating: Negative Comment: I see no reason to give this member, Shiori, anymore time to reply to me since there is yet another member who didn't receive their books from her and has left a message to this effect. That makes 6 different members that I know of who have been ripped off. Yes, ripped off I do believe is the case here. Shiori was to be in touch with me no later than Saturday the 10th. She logged on Sunday the 11th but did not message me. I'd had an ok trade with this member in the past, though she was extremely slow in mailing. I assumed that was the case this time. However, her statment on her bio of not shipping until she receives gave me an uneasy feeling. Considering we'd traded successfully in the past, I felt this shouldn't have applied to me, but went ahead with the trade she approached me on anyway. Should not have done this obviously. A month ago she acknowledged receiving the books I shipped to her. This feedback will be changed should I ever receive my books. Rated by: isabeau Date: 2009-01-14 23:13:15
Rating: Negative Comment: Never received item.
Agreed to trade: 11-14-2008
She acknowledged receiving my book on 11-29-2008 only after I asked her, as I had received neither the book nor any communication.
On 12-11-2008 I asked her about it again, and the next day she replied that she'd check with the post office. She hasn't responded to any subsequent messages despite having logged on since I left them for her.
Basically, at this point I have no choice but to consider her a thief, especially as she's apparently done this to someone else since I agreed to trade with her.
I will of course change the review if she acts to resolve this situation. Rated by: nova14 Date: 2009-01-11 18:35:56
Rating: Good Comment: Thanks again for the books! Rated by: canonhoney Date: 2009-01-07 00:26:17
Rating: Good Comment: Great trade - fast shipping and book in good condition - thanks! Rated by: tiggerpuss Date: 2008-11-26 08:45:17
Rating: Good Comment: Great trade - fast shipping and book in good condition - thanks! Rated by: tiggerpuss Date: 2008-11-26 08:42:51
Rating: Good Comment: Great trade - fast shipping and book in good condition - thanks! Rated by: tiggerpuss Date: 2008-11-26 08:38:05
Rating: Good Comment: Great! No problems at all, great book! Thanks for trading! Rated by: mook362 Date: 2008-11-23 19:26:24
Rating: Good Comment: thx for the trade :) Rated by: shouhaku Date: 2008-11-18 11:00:53
Rating: Good Comment: Went well.thanks. Rated by: CC Date: 2008-11-16 11:39:15
Rating: Good Comment: Great trader, good Communication, items arrived safely. Thanks again! :3 Rated by: catgirl_luna Date: 2008-11-14 19:29:34
Rating: Good Comment: Great trader, good Communication, items arrived safely. Thanks again! :3 Rated by: catgirl_luna Date: 2008-11-14 19:29:22
Rating: Good Comment: Great trader, good Communication, items arrived safely. Thanks again! :3 Rated by: catgirl_luna Date: 2008-11-14 19:29:07
Rating: Good Comment: Great trader, sent fast! Rated by: Luvdarain5 Date: 2008-11-14 15:27:58
Rating: Good Comment: Recieved the book today; it came quickly and in great condition. Thanks, Shiori! Rated by: Jack Date: 2008-10-31 18:07:34
Rating: Good Comment: Came pretty quickly and in great condition! Rated by: hil34 Date: 2008-10-29 19:52:05
Rating: Good Comment: I got everything and it looked GREAT! thanks a lot! I'd love to trade with you again sometime! ;3 Rated by: Misa Date: 2008-10-24 15:08:14
Rating: Good Comment: work out well thanks Rated by: CC Date: 2008-10-23 20:06:39
Rating: Good Comment: Thanks for the smooth trade! Rated by: AsimovGirl Date: 2008-10-17 12:11:19
Rating: Good Comment: Went great. Thanks for the book Rated by: CC Date: 2008-10-16 21:12:45
Rating: Good Comment: Book is excellent. Slow shipping however. Rated by: isabeau Date: 2008-10-16 20:08:28
Rating: Good Comment: Book is excellent. Slow shipping however. Rated by: isabeau Date: 2008-10-16 20:07:43
Rating: Good Comment: Book is excellent. Slow shipping however. Rated by: isabeau Date: 2008-10-16 20:06:49
Rating: Good Comment: Book is fine. Slow shipping. Rated by: isabeau Date: 2008-10-16 20:06:03
Rating: Good Comment: Came quickly and in great condition! Rated by: hil34 Date: 2008-10-03 16:51:03
Rating: Good Comment: Great! thanks so much always wanted to read it Rated by: CC Date: 2008-09-25 19:39:10
Rating: Good Comment: :D good trade. +! Rated by: greybit Date: 2008-09-23 17:40:55
Rating: Good Comment: The book came! Thank you very much!! Rated by: GingerSnaps Date: 2008-09-20 14:47:48
